The Star and Lantern: An interview that went too well
Searching the archives of the Forgotten Footpath Society is a rewarding, if occasionally unsettling, pastime. The records are full of odd encounters, hidden places, and happenings that resist straightforward explanation. Among these, the Star and Lantern has always stood out, the so-called 'phase pub' first documented in issue 15, and I've continued to look out for records of subsequent sightings.
One recently came to light, filed under 'Anomalous Establishments, overflow'. The notes were made by Rosalind Quaich on 15 June 2022, following what had begun as a routine walk from Berwick St John.
The weather was overcast, with a specific quality of grey that Rosalind noted as feeling 'deliberate'.
Four members attended, Rosalind acting as leader, plus Gerald, Pamela, and a new recruit named Owen. Owen had joined after responding to the society's notice in the shop in Sixpenny Handley, and this was his first walk. Owen said he'd been looking for the society for years. Gerald said the notice had only gone up the previous Tuesday.
The group were not intending to find the pub, although most experienced members always hoped they might. The notes from the first visit suggested that don't go looking was the best way to find it.
Somehow, they strayed from the path and in trying to find it again they went through a gap in a hedge and emerged into a clearing that was not on any map, in winter light that was several months out of season.
The pub was there, right in front of them, the sign reading The Star and Lantern, Est. ??? Smoke curled from the chimney.
A black horse was tethered outside. It turned its head and looked at Gerald for an uncomfortably long time.
"It recognises something," said Owen.
"It doesn't know me," said Gerald defensively.
The man by the wall
Then they saw the man, if man he was. He was crouched by the wall and wore a long coat the colour of lichen and boots that had seen many miles. His hat was wide-brimmed and looked damp. Rosalind noted: could be forty, could be four hundred, face that's been rained on a lot.
He was examining something in his palm. When the group approached he closed his hand around it.
"You came back," he said, without looking up.
"We haven't been before," said Pamela.
"That's not really what I mean," he said.
He turned to look at them and stood, and was taller than expected. The horse made a sound of acknowledgment. He put one hand on its flank without looking at it.
His name, offered unprompted and in a tone that suggested it might not be entirely accurate, was Aldric.
Rosalind asked if he was waiting for someone.
"Oh yes," he said, and looked at Owen for a moment that had some weight to it.
Inside
The group went into the pub. Rosalind, who had read the notes of the previous FFS visit several times, immediately recognised Elowen behind the bar. Elowen gave Rosalind a look that suggested she had been expecting this.
Silas was also there, writing something in a ledger. Gerald said hello. Silas put a hand over the page. At the far end of the bar, a woman in a dark coat was reading a newspaper dated from 1987.
"Are you open?" asked Pamela.
"For what?" said Silas.
Pamela said she meant for drinks. Silas tilted his head. Elowen brought them each a small glass of something golden without being asked.
"Gatekeeper's Gold?" asked Rosalind.
"Threshold Pale," said Elowen. "Similar principle. Different occasion."
It tasted like morning light on chalk. A general sense of being assessed that had begun outside intensified, feeling less like surveillance, Rosalind noted, and more like an interview that was going well.
Owen didn't touch his. Elowen noticed. The grain of the bar surface rippled slightly. In the corner, a man with his back to them was folding and refolding a map. Each time he unfolded it, it was a different place. When Rosalind looked back at the woman with the newspaper, she was watching Owen with an expression of recognition.
The compass
They were sitting at a table by the fire when Aldric came inside. He sat across from Owen and placed, carefully, on the tabletop between them, a compass. Small, brass, very old. The needle turned slowly, continuously, with great purpose.
"This has been doing that for many, many years," said Aldric. "Since it was taken from where it belongs."
Owen looked at it with an expression that Rosalind struggled to describe. Recognition was part of it. Reluctance was part of it. The rest, she noted, I can't account for yet.
"Where's that?" said Rosalind.
Aldric pulled a face. "Not so much where but who. An old one. The compass was made to find this someone, and it will, but the person who carries it has to be the right person. Otherwise it just..." he gestured. "Does that."
The woman with the newspaper was now watching them closely. The man with the map had stopped refolding it and was listening, head to one side, though his back remained turned.
"And Owen is the right person?" said Gerald.
"Owen was always going to be the right person," said Aldric. "I've been looking for someone the compass will settle for, and it's been unsettled for a very long time."
Owen said: "I found the FFS notice in the shop in Sixpenny Handley."
Aldric said: "Yes."
Owen said: "You put it there."
Aldric said: "I put it in a number of places. That one worked."
Gerald said, indignantly: "I put that notice up."
Aldric smiled at him and said: "Gerald. Yes. I know." The way he said it closed that line of enquiry with a kind of finality and authority, like a very old door that shuts without a sound.
Elowen arrived from nowhere with a piece of paper, which she set on the table. The writing on it was small and dense. Rosalind copied what she could. As she wrote, she became aware that the other customers had drawn slightly closer.
The bearer of the compass undertakes: to follow where it leads; to remain the right kind of lost; to return the compass to its rightful owner; and not to open the compass.
"Why not open it?" asked Pamela.
"Because it's not a compass," said Elowen.
A pause. The fire crackled. Silas's pen stopped scratching in his ledger.
"It's a compass," said Aldric at last, in the tone of someone contradicting a statement they made themselves. "But it's also something else. And the something else is not ready to be looked at yet."
"What happens if you open it?" said Rosalind.
Aldric and Elowen looked at each other. A conversation took place in that look which lasted approximately six seconds and covered a great deal of ground. Behind them, the woman with the newspaper had begun to smile to herself. The man with the map had turned slightly towards them.
"Just don't," said Aldric. "I don't want to have to start again." He said this with the exhaustion of someone describing something that had already happened at least once.
Owen's decision
Owen picked up the compass. The needle stopped moving.
It pointed. A fixed, certain, direction.
"That's good," said Aldric, quietly.
Owen looked at the direction the needle was pointing, at the back wall of the pub, but despite it's sturdy stone construction the wall didn't seem to feel this was an insurmountable problem. As he stared at it, Rosalind noticed the stone beginning to lighten almost imperceptibly.
The woman with the newspaper stood and folded it with great care. The man with the map had turned fully now, though Rosalind couldn't hold his face in her mind. Silas had closed his ledger. Elowen was watching Owen with an expression of deep admiration.
"Can I finish my drink first?" said Owen.
"The drink will wait," said Elowen.
Owen drank it anyway. Elowen's expression did not change, but there was something in the set of her shoulders that suggested approval.
He stood. The compass needle trembled slightly, as if recognising the moment. Aldric stood as well, and inclined his head in a gesture that might have been respect, or farewell, or both.
Owen walked toward the back wall. The other customers watched in absolute silence.
Rosalind caught a glimpse of grey rock and wind-bent grass, the sky, the sea, and something that might have been a figure waiting.
Then Owen was gone.
No one moved. Pamela's hand had gone to her mouth. Gerald was staring at the space where Owen had been. Elowen was clearing glasses. Silas had opened his ledger again. The woman with the newspaper had returned to her seat. The man with the map put it in a bag and left by the door. Everything continued as if nothing had happened.
Departure
They found themselves leaving the pub without having thought about it. Outside, they turned back towards the door, but the pub was gone. A horse whinnied in the distance.
The afternoon light was wrong. It had been mid-afternoon when they entered; now it felt like the hour before dusk, though the sun hadn't moved noticeably. Gerald checked his watch. It had stopped at 3:47.
Rosalind's notes on this said: We stood there for a moment. Pamela asked if we ought to wait. Gerald said he didn't know what for. We walked back to the car. We didn't talk much. The walk was 7.4 miles.
Proof
Rosalind found a note in her coat pocket the next day. It was written in handwriting that wasn't hers and wasn't anyone's she recognised.
He's going the right way. Don't worry.
E
Three days later she received a postcard showing Valley of the Rocks, North Devon. It was from Owen:
Starting here, heading south. Not sure where to, but found a friend. The compass knows the way. Will keep in touch!
Status of Owen
Pending clarification. Then a handwritten note: Returned 24 June 2022, sans compass, with the energy of someone who has thoroughly enjoyed a secret holiday. Had a pocketful of sea glass. Keeps staring at empty corners as if expecting something to happen. Debriefed immediately by Sylvia, the president. See President's Restricted Files for more details (by permission only). Includes full audio with transcripts.
Filed by: R. Quaich.